Change fails when people
aren’t brought with it.
Change management conflict rarely starts with the financial case for a merger or restructure. It is the human element – culture, identity, communication and trust – that determines whether change delivers its intended return or creates a different, more expensive problem.
Sources: Christensen, Alton, Rising & Waldeck – The New M&A Playbook (Harvard Business Review, 2011); ReWAGE policy brief on the cost of conflict. The ReWAGE figures describe workplace conflict as a whole rather than conflict during change specifically, and the HBR range is given in the article summary without supporting data.
The core challenge
Change programmes and M&A activity are almost always designed and evaluated in financial and operational terms. What tends not to be measured, until it is already a problem, is the human cost: the anxiety of staff who don’t know what the change means for them, the friction between two cultures that have been told they are now one, the resentment of managers expected to deliver change they haven’t been genuinely consulted on, and the quiet exodus of the most capable people who had the most options.
By the time these dynamics become visible – in attrition data, engagement scores, or formal grievances – the damage is already significant. Early, structured intervention changes the trajectory before it reaches that point.
Two distinct situations
Our work in this area falls across two related but meaningfully different contexts.
Mergers and acquisitions
When two businesses combine, the deal settles ownership and price but says nothing about how each side makes decisions, handles disagreement or decides who gets consulted, so colleagues are left to work those habits out between themselves once the announcement has been made. The disputes that follow are often read as personality clashes, when what is actually meeting for the first time is two sets of unwritten rules.
Internal restructuring and change
A redundancy round, a change of leadership, a departmental reorganisation or a period of rapid growth each alters who people report to and what their work is for, and while those questions remain open colleagues look to each other for answers that nobody can yet give, read each other’s motives less generously and carry disagreements further than they would in a settled team.
What published research says about people and change
In a merger, the first question is about jobs
McKinsey’s work on talent in M&A identifies whether people will still have a job in the new organisation as the primary concern of most employees, and notes that who is appointed to senior roles signals the culture of the combined business.
BasisMcKinsey practitioner article, citing a survey of more than 1,400 integration executives
Source: McKinsey article (opens in new tab)“Will I have a job in the new organization?” … “that is the primary concern of most employees.”
“the outcomes send a message to all employees about the values and culture they will experience in the combined organization.”
The article (Chao, Kaetzler, Lalani and Lynch, 12 October 2020) also reports a McKinsey survey in which praise from an immediate manager was ranked as the most effective retention lever. It is a practitioner article rather than a peer-reviewed study.
The difficulty often lies in how change is managed
The CIPD’s guide for people professionals makes the point that the challenge is often not the change itself but the way it is managed and embedded in the workplace.
BasisCIPD guide for people professionals, December 2024
Source: CIPD change guide (opens in new tab)“Often it is not the change itself that is challenging, but the way change is managed and embedded in the workplace.”
Most of the guide is open to CIPD members only. This line comes from the public introduction, so the tile reflects the CIPD’s framing rather than any figure from the full text.
Unclear roles reduce people’s support for change
A survey study at a large transportation company found that unclear job descriptions reduced employees’ willingness to do the voluntary extra work that helps change succeed, an effect that was softened where people felt passion for their work, harmony with colleagues and commitment to the organisation.
BasisEmployee survey at one company, published in the Journal of General Management
Source: De Clercq & Pereira (opens in new tab)The authors define change-oriented organisational citizenship behaviour as voluntary, extra-role work that supports change. They found that role ambiguity weakened it, and that work passion, peer harmony and affective commitment each buffered that effect. They conclude that organisations may not be able to remove role ambiguity entirely, but can sustain some of this behaviour by building those resources.
De Clercq, D. and Pereira, R., When does role ambiguity escalate into diminished change-oriented organizational citizenship behavior?, Journal of General Management 51(3), first published online July 2023. It draws on one company’s survey data, so it points to a pattern rather than settling the question.
The people who stay carry the aftermath
In interviews with 15 employees who kept their jobs after Airbnb’s COVID-19 layoffs, people described sharply higher workloads and guilt or anxiety at watching colleagues leave, and said that regular check-ins and open communication helped them keep their sense that the process was fair.
Basis15 interviews at one company, published in Sustainability
Source: Lee et al., 2023 (opens in new tab)Survivors took on the duties of departed colleagues and workloads rose sharply. Participants reported guilt, anxiety and low motivation after watching colleagues leave. Interactive and informational justice, meaning respectful treatment and honest explanations, featured especially strongly in how they judged the process.
Lee, S., Hong, S., Shin, W.-Y. and Lee, B.G. (2023), The Experiences of Layoff Survivors: Navigating Organizational Justice in Times of Crisis, Sustainability 15(24), 16717. It covers one company and a small sample at a single point in mid-2020, which the authors say limits how far it generalises, and its findings on engagement and satisfaction were mixed.
Where change management conflict typically arises
The specific fault lines differ between M&A and internal restructuring, but the underlying dynamics – identity threat, role uncertainty, and broken trust – are consistent.
-
Cultural collision
Two organisations with different cultures, hierarchies, and communication styles are declared one entity. The friction this creates is immediate, persistent, and almost always underestimated.
-
Leadership uncertainty
When senior roles are duplicated following a merger, or vacated by a restructure, the resulting power vacuum generates political behaviour and interpersonal conflict that distracts from operational delivery.
-
Identity and belonging
Employees whose organisation has been acquired – or whose team has been reorganised out of existence – experience a genuine loss of professional identity. The resentment this generates is routinely mistaken for resistance to change.
-
Communication breakdown
The most damaging communication failure during change is not what is said incorrectly – it is what is not said at all. Silence from leadership during uncertainty is consistently interpreted as bad news.
-
Manager overload
Middle managers are asked to process their own uncertainty while communicating confidence to their teams. Without specific support, this generates stress, burnout, and avoidant management behaviour.
-
Post-change attrition
The most capable employees – those with the strongest external options – leave first. The talent loss that follows a poorly managed change programme is often its most significant and least recoverable cost.
Our services for change and M&A
Yorway does not design or run change programmes, and does not give legal advice. We work alongside them on the conflict and psychological side of change, through four services that can each be used on their own or together.
Workplace mediation
For disputes that have already formed around a change, whether between colleagues, between a manager and their team, or between leaders, and where the people involved are willing to take part.
How it is deliveredTypically a one to three day engagement, in person or by secure video, led by William Heseltine, CMC Associate Mediator (Workplace).
- Individual pre-mediation meetings with each party
- A facilitated joint session, including between colleagues or teams from legacy organisations after a merger
- Facilitated discussions at board or leadership level where the conflict is a senior one
- Advisory support to HR and legal teams alongside formal procedures, including difficult departures
- A written record of agreed outcomes, and a follow-up check-in at 30 days
Commercial mediation
For disputes between businesses that arise around a merger, sale or restructure, for example between co-directors, shareholders or business partners, or between a company and a supplier or customer. It is also suited to disputes within family-run businesses.
How it is deliveredTypically a full-day mediation, preceded by a conversation with each party, in person or by secure video, led by William Heseltine, CMC Registered Mediator (Civil/Commercial). Fees are agreed in advance.
- A pre-mediation conversation with each party to clarify the issues, interests and expectations
- A facilitated session led by a CMC Registered Mediator (Civil/Commercial)
- A confidential, voluntary process in which no outcome is imposed
- A written record of any agreement, provided to all parties
- Conflict coaching beforehand, for anyone who wants to prepare
Conflict coaching and training
For managers and leaders carrying a difficult situation through a change, for anyone in conflict whose other party will not take part in mediation, and for teams that want practical skills for handling disagreement.
How it is deliveredConflict coaching sessions last 90 minutes, online or in person. Workshops run for a half or full day, scoped in a conversation beforehand.
- 1:1 conflict coaching for managers and leaders in high-friction roles
- Coaching for individuals in conflict where the other party will not take part in mediation
- Preparing for difficult conversations with teams and colleagues
- Workshops on handling difficult conversations, resilient leadership and psychological safety
- CBT-informed group sessions on stress, burnout prevention and emotional regulation
Yorway Insights
For finding out how people are coping with a change while it is happening, rather than waiting for attrition figures or grievances to show it.
How it is deliveredWe set up the survey for your organisation and issue a private link. Your people answer anonymously, and the results appear in a secure dashboard that shows your organisation’s data only.
- The Change & Transition survey, on how a workforce is coping with a restructure or merger, covering clarity, trust and support
- Anonymous responses, with results broken down by team so you can see which part of the organisation needs support
- Repeat surveys, to show whether things are improving as the change progresses
- Companion surveys including Conflict Insights, Post-Mediation Review and Leadership Feedback
Protect the value your change programme is meant to create.
A free initial consultation costs nothing and commits you to nothing. We’ll listen to where you are in the change process and recommend the most appropriate next step – in confidence.